Skip to main content

Supreme Court Black Film Ban Review Verdict (Avishek Goenka Order): Hyderabad Car Glass Rules

Last updated:
Quick Summary: On August 3, 2012, the Supreme Court of India dismissed all modification and clarification applications filed by tint-film dealers against the Avishek Goenka black film ban. Across Hyderabad, Cyberabad, and Rachakonda today, pasting any aftermarket film of any Visual Light Transmission (VLT) percentage on vehicle glass remains strictly illegal under CMVR Rule 100.

After the Supreme Court prohibited tinted sun films nationwide on April 27, 2012, several dealers, distributors, and vehicle associations filed interim applications (I.A. Nos. 4 to 15 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 265 of 2011, Avishek Goenka v. Union of India) seeking modification or relaxation of the order. Following an earlier Registrar dismissal on May 16, 2012, a two-judge bench of Justice A.K. Patnaik and Justice Swatanter Kumar delivered a reportable judgment on August 3, 2012 closing the door on aftermarket films completely.

Five Operative Directions from the Supreme Court Review Order

The bench ruled that Rule 100 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules (CMVR), 1989 prescribes VLT standards exclusively for factory-manufactured safety glass—not for aftermarket adhesive sheets pasted over clear glass. The Court issued five binding directions:

DirectionSupreme Court Mandate (August 3, 2012)
1. Applications DismissedAll petitions seeking clarification, relaxation, or modification of the April 27, 2012 ban were dismissed without costs.
2. Zero Aftermarket FilmEvery Director General of Police (DGP) and Commissioner of Police must ensure no material—including clear or lightly tinted film of any VLT—is pasted on safety glass.
3. Challan Plus Immediate RemovalTraffic police must not merely issue a fine; officers are directed to ensure illegal black film or pasted material is peeled off forthwith.
4. Contempt WarningThe Court warned that continued non-enforcement by police leadership could invite action under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.
5. Nationwide CirculationCopies of the order were sent directly to all State Chief Secretaries for uniform enforcement.

What Is Legal for Car Windows in Hyderabad Today?

Car owners in Hyderabad, Cyberabad, and Rachakonda often confuse OEM factory-tinted glass with aftermarket sun-control film. Under CMVR Rule 100 and MoRTH Parivahan standards:

  • Factory-Fitted Safety Glass Only: Front and rear windscreens must maintain at least 70% VLT, while side windows must allow at least 50% VLT—built into the glass during manufacture, never added as film.
  • No Magnetic Sunshades or Curtains While Driving: Removable mesh shades, suction pads, and window curtains are also treated as visibility obstructions during moving traffic drives; read our Hyderabad Car Curtains & Sunshade Rules Guide for full details.
  • Check Fines & Enforcement: Vehicles stopped during special drives face on-spot stripping of films plus e-Challans under the Motor Vehicles Act; review penalty amounts in our Hyderabad Traffic Fines Chart and statutory provisions in the Motor Vehicles Act Reference, or check pending tickets on echallan.tspolice.gov.in.

To stay cool during Hyderabad summers legally, opt for OEM UV-cut glass available on newer trims, park in covered bays, use removable reflective sunshades only while parked, and maintain cabin AC filters.

Historical Context: This judgment (originally archived here in October 2012 as Part 2 of the review order) followed the Supreme Court's initial April 27, 2012 ban and the Registrar's May 16, 2012 rejection of dealer modification pleas, cementing strict enforcement across Hyderabad ever since.

From the Archive: Original Post of 26 October 2012

The text below is reproduced as it was published on this blog on 26 October 2012 under the title “Supreme Court Judgement on Review Petitions submitted against Ban on Black Films Part -2”. It is kept as a historical record: the amounts, phone numbers, office-holders and arrangements in it are those of that date and may no longer apply.

Note: Following Judgement was passed after review petitions were filed by various parties following the judgement passed on 27 April 2012.

Judgement Part -2

Judgement Date - 16 May 2012

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

IA NOS. 4, 5, IA NOS. 6-8, IA. NOS. 9-11, 12, 13, 14 AND 15

IN

WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO.265 OF 2011

Avishek Goenka ... Appellant

Versus

Union of India & Anr. ... Respondents

J U D G M E N T

Swatanter Kumar, J.

1. The applications for impleadment and intervention are allowed subject

to just exceptions. All applications for placing documents on record are

also allowed.

2. I.A. No. 5 of 2012 has been filed by the Dealers and Distributors of

tinted films in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 265 of 2011 under Order XVIII,

Rule 5 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1966 against the dismissal of two

interim applications, i.e., seeking permission to file application for

impleadment and application for modification by the Registrar of this Court

vide his Order dated 16th May, 2012.

3. The learned Registrar vide the impugned order noticed that

application for impleadment was not maintainable inasmuch as the writ

petition in which the application was filed has already been disposed of.

In regard to the application for modification, according to the applicants,

the petitioner suppressed various aspects of the matter and misled the

court in passing the order and the same order was therefore, liable to be

modified. Dealing with this contention, the learned Registrar, while

referring to the judgment of this Court in Delhi Administration v. Gurdip

Singh Uban and Ors. [(2000) 7 SCC 269] held that the application, in fact,

was an application for review and not for modification. Thus, he declined

to receive the application and registered the same in accordance with the

Rules of the Supreme Court.

4. We hardly find any error of law in the Order of the Registrar under

appeal, but we consider it entirely unnecessary to deliberate upon this

issue in any further detail, since, we have permitted the applicants to

address the Court on merits of the application. Keeping in view the fact

that a number of other applications have been filed for clarification and

modification of the judgment of this Court dated 27th April, 2012, without

commenting upon the merit or otherwise of the present appeal, we would deal

only with the application for modification or clarification filed by these

applicants along with others.

5. I.A. No. 15 has been filed by the International Window Film

Association. I.A. No. 4 has been filed on behalf of Vipul Gambhir.

6. An unnumbered I.A. of 2012 is filed by 3M India Ltd. Another

unnumbered I.A. has been filed on behalf of the dealers and distributors of

the tinted films.

7. I.A. No. 3 of 2012, an application on behalf of the petitioner to

appear in person, is allowed.

8. I.A. No. 7 of 2012 has been filed on behalf of M/s. Garware Polyester

Ltd. I.A. No. 10 of 2012 is an application filed by M/s. Car Owners and

Consumer Association.

9. Another unnumbered I.A. has been filed on behalf of M/s. Gras

Impex Pvt. Ltd. All these applications have been filed by various

applicants seeking clarification and/or modification of the judgment of

this Court dated 27th April, 2012 on various grounds.

10. The petitioner has filed I.A. No. 11 of 2012 by way of a common reply

to the grounds taken in all these applications and has also placed certain

documents on record. The various applicants above-named have sought

modification/clarification of the judgment of this Court dated 27th April,

2012 principally and with emphasis on the following grounds :

1) That the applicants were not parties to the writ petition and were not

aware of the proceedings before this Court. Thus, their submissions

could not be considered by the Court, hence the judgment of the Court

requires modification.

2) The applicants have placed material and reports on record that the use

of films or even black films is permissible scientifically and in law.

3) It is contended that Rule 100(2) uses the expression ‘maintained’ which

implies that safety glasses, including the wind screen, can be maintained

with requisite VLT percentage even by use of black films.

4) Lastly, it is contended that para 27 of the judgment needs modification

by substituting the words ‘use of black films of any VLT percentage’ by

the words ‘use of black films of impermissible VLT percentage”.

11. We must notice at the very threshold that in the main Writ Petition

no. 265 of 2011 and even in the present applications, there is no challenge

to Rule 100 of the Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 (for short, ‘the Rules’).

This Court vide its judgment dated 27th April, 2012, has interpreted the

said Rule de hors the other factors. Once this Court interprets a

provision of law, the law so declared would be the law of the land in terms

of Article 141 of the Constitution of India. The law so declared is

binding on all and must be enforced in terms thereof. Having interpreted

the Rule to mean that it is the safety glasses alone with requisite VLT

that can be fixed in a vehicle, it is not for this Court to change the

language of the said Rule. It would, primarily, be a legislative function

and no role herein, is to be performed by this Court.

12. In the applications before us, as already noticed, some grounds have

been taken to demonstrate that some other interpretation of the provision

was possible. These grounds, firstly, are not grounds of law. They are

primarily the grounds of inconvenience. Enforcement of law, if causes any

inconvenience, is no ground for rendering a provision on the statute book

to be unenforceable. The challenge to the legislative act can be raised on

very limited grounds and certainly not the ones raised in the present

application. In fact, all the learned counsel appearing for various

applicants fairly conceded that they were not raising any challenge to Rule

100 of the Rules. Once that position is accepted, we see no reason to

alter the interpretation given by us to the said Rule in our judgment dated

27th April, 2012.

13. Still, we will proceed to discuss the contentions raised. The

judgment dated 27th April, 2012 was passed in a Public Interest Litigation

and the orders passed by this Court would be operative in rem. It was

neither expected of the Court nor is it the requirement of law that the

Court should have issued notice to every shopkeeper selling the films,

every distributor distributing the films and every manufacturer

manufacturing the films. But, in any case, this was a widely covered

matter by the Press. It was incumbent upon the applicants to approach the

Court, if they wanted to be heard at that stage. The writ petition was

instituted on 6th May, 2011 and the judgment in the case was pronounced

after hearing all concerned, including the Union Government, on 27th April,

2012, nearly after a year. Hence, this ground raised by the applicants

requires noticing only for being rejected.

14. Not only the present judgment but even the previous judgments of this

Court, in the cases referred to in the judgment dated 27th April, 2012, in

some detail have never permitted use of films on the glasses. What the

Court permitted was tinted glasses with requisite VLT. Thus, the view of

this Court has been consistent and does not require any clarification or

modification.

15. Equally, without substance and merit is the submission that the

expression ‘maintained’ used in Rule 100 would imply that subsequent to

manufacturing, the car can be maintained by use of films with requisite VLT

of 70 per cent and 50 per cent respectively. In the judgment, after

discussing the scheme of the Act, the Rules framed thereunder and Rule 100

read in conjunction with Indian Standard No.2553 Part II of 1992, this

court took the view that the Rule does not permit use of any other material

except the safety glass ‘manufactured as per the requirements of law’.

Rule 100 categorically states that ‘safety glass’ is the glass which is to

be manufactured as per the specification and requirements of explanation to

Rule 100(1). It is only the safety glasses alone that can be used by the

manufacturer of the vehicle. The requisite VLT has to be 70 per cent and

50 per cent of the screen and side windows respectively, without external

aid of any kind of material, including the films pasted on the safety

glasses. The use of film on the glass would change the very concept and

requirements of safety glass in accordance with law. The expression

‘maintained’ has to be construed to say that, what is required to be

manufactured in accordance with law should be continued to be maintained as

such. ‘Maintenance’ has to be construed ejusdem generis to manufacture and

cannot be interpreted in a manner that alterations to motor vehicles in

violation of the specific rules have been impliedly permitted under the

language of the Rule itself. The basic features and requirements of safety

glass are not subject to any alteration. If the interpretation given by

the applicants is accepted, it would frustrate the very purpose of enacting

Rule 100 and would also hurt the safety requirements of a motor vehicle as

required under the Act. Number of Rules have been discussed in the

judgment dated 27th April, 2012 to demonstrate that these Rules are

required to be strictly construed otherwise they would lead to disastrous

results and would frustrate the very purpose of enacting such law.

16. Now, we may come to the last contention that para 27 of the judgment

needs modification as noticed above. Para 27 of the judgment reads as

under:

“27. For the reasons afore-stated, we prohibit the use of black

films of any VLT percentage or any other material upon the

safety glasses, windscreens (front and rear) and side glasses of

all vehicles throughout the country. The Home Secretary,

Director General/Commissioner of Police of the respective

States/Centre shall ensure compliance with this direction. The

directions contained in this judgment shall become operative and

enforceable with effect from 4th May, 2012.”

17. According to the applicant, the expression ‘we prohibit the use of

black film of any VLT percentage or any other material upon safety glasses’

should be substituted by ‘we prohibit the use of black films of

impermissible VLT percentage or any other material upon the safety

glasses’. The suggestion of the applicants would be in complete violation

of the substantive part of the judgment. We have already noticed that it

is not the extent of VLT percentage of films which is objectionable under

the Rules but it is the very use of black films or any other material,

which is impermissible to be used on the safety glasses. Once the

prescribed specifications do not contemplate use of any other material

except what is specified in the Explanation to Rule 100(1), then the use of

any such material by implication cannot be permitted. Quando aliquid

prohibetur ex directo, prohibetur et per obliquum. If we substitute the

plain language in para 27, it would render the entire judgment ineffective

and contradictory in terms. Having already held that no material,

including the films, can be used on the safety glasses, there is no

occasion for us to accept this contention as well.

18. The manufacturer and distributors have placed certain material before

us, including some photographs and reports of the American Cancer Society,

to show that mostly skin cancer is caused by too much exposure to ultra-

violet rays. From these photographs, attempt is made to show that in the

day time when the films are pasted upon the safety glasses, still the face

and the body of the occupant of the car is visible from outside. It is also

stated that certain amendments were proposed in the Code of Virginia

relating to the use of sun shading and tinting films, on the motor

vehicles. Relying upon the material relating to America, it is stated that

there are large number of cancer cases in USA and the framers of the law

have amended the provisions or are in the process of amending the

provisions. This itself shows that it is a case of change in law and not

one of improper interpretation, which is not the function of this Court.

19. To counter this, the petitioner has filed a detailed reply supported

by various documents. This shows that tinted glasses have been banned in a

number of countries and it is not permissible to use such glasses on the

windows of the vehicle. Annexure A1 and A3 have been placed on record in

relation to New South Wales, Australia, Afghanistan and some other

countries. He has also placed on record a complete research article on the

cancer scenario in India with future perspective which has specifically

compared India as a developing country with developed countries like USA

and has found that cancer is much less in India despite the fact that most

of the Indian population is exposed to ultra-violet rays for the larger

part of the day for earning their livelihood for their daily works,

business and other activities.

20. This controversy arising from the submissions founded on factual

matrix does not, in our opinion, call for any determination before this

Court. As already noticed, the Court has interpreted Rule 100 as it exists

on the statute book. The environment, atmosphere and geographical

conditions of each country are different. The level of tolerance and

likelihood of exposure to a disease through sun rays or otherwise are

subjective matters incapable of being examined objectively in judicial

sense. The Courts are neither required to venture upon such determination

nor would it be advisable.

21. It cannot be disputed and is a matter of common knowledge that there

are a large number of preventive measures that can be taken by a person who

needs to protect himself from the ultra-violet rays. Use of creams, sun-

shed and other amenities would be beneficial for the individual alleged to

be intolerable to sun rays. It does not require change of a permanent

character in the motor vehicle, that too, in utter violation of the

provisions of the statute. Suffice it to note that the reliance placed

upon the literature before us is misconceived and misdirected. The

interpretation of law is not founded on a single circumstance, particularly

when such circumstance is so very individualistic. The Court is not

expected to go into individual cases while dealing with interpretation of

law. It is a settled canon of interpretative jurisprudence that hardship

of few cannot be the basis for determining the validity of any statute.

The law must be interpreted and applied on its plain language. (Ref.

Saurabh Chaudri & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. [AIR 2004 SC 361].

22. In IA 4, a similar request is made. We are not dealing with

individual cases and individual inconvenience cannot be a ground for giving

the law a different interpretation.

23. The petitioner argued with some vehemence that despite a clear

direction of this Court, the appellate authority has utterly failed in

enforcing the law. According to him, in majority of the vehicles in the

NCT Delhi and the surrounding districts of UP, like Ghaziabad, Noida as

well as towns of Haryana surrounding Delhi, law is violated with impunity.

All safety glasses are posted either with Jet black films or light coloured

films. He has referred to two instances, one of rape in Ghaziabad and the

other of kidnapping, where the cars involved in the commission of the crime

had black films. He has also stated that as per the press reports, the

vehicles which are involved in hit and run cases are also vehicles with

black films posted on the safety glasses.

24. We are really not emphasizing on the security threat to the society

at large by use of black films but it is a clear violation of law. In

terms of Rule 100, no material including films of any VLT can be pasted on

the safety glasses of the car and this law is required to be enforced

without demur and delay. Thus, we pass the following orders :

1) All the applications filed for clarification and modification are

dismissed, however, without any order as to costs.

2) All the Director Generals of Police/Commissioners of Police are

hereby again directed to ensure complete compliance of the judgment

of this Court in its true spirit and substance. They shall not

permit pasting of any material, including films of any VLT, on the

safety glasses of any vehicle.

3) We reiterate that the police authorities shall not only challan the

offenders but ensure that the black or any other films or material

pasted on the safety glasses are removed forthwith.

4) We make it clear at this stage that we would not initiate any

proceedings against the Director Generals of Police/Commissioners of

Police of the respective States/Union Territories but issue a clear

warning that in the event of non-compliance of the judgment of this

Court now, and upon it being brought to the notice of this Court,

the Court shall be compelled to take appropriate action under the

provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 without any further

notice to the said officers.

We do express a pious hope that the high responsible officers of the

police cadre like Director General/Commissioner of Police would not

permit such a situation to arise and would now ensure compliance of

the judgment without default, demur and delay.

5) Copies of this judgment be sent to all concerned by the Registry

including the Chief Secretaries of the respective States forthwith.

…….…………......................J.

(A.K. Patnaik)

...….…………......................J.

(Swatanter Kumar)

New Delhi

August 3, 2012

Source credited in the original post: htp.gov.in Press Release and Supreme Court Order.

Informational Notice: This page is an independent citizen guide for Greater Hyderabad commuters and is not affiliated with the police or any government department. Verify official challans, rules, and filings directly on echallan.tspolice.gov.in, tgtransport.net, or parivahan.gov.in.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hyderabad Traffic Police e-Challan Status Check Online (Telangana)

Last updated: 19 November 2026 Quick Official Link: Check and pay pending traffic challans for Hyderabad, Cyberabad, and Rachakonda (and all Telangana districts) directly on the official Telangana State Police Integrated e-Challan portal: https://echallan.tspolice.gov.in/publicview/ . If your vehicle was photographed by a traffic surveillance camera, ANPR (Automatic Number Plate Recognition) camera, speed laser gun, or field officer in Hyderabad, Cyberabad, Rachakonda, or anywhere in Telangana, the violation is logged centrally on the Telangana State Police Integrated e-Challan System . You do not need separate portals for Hyderabad and Cyberabad anymore—one lookup covers all three Greater Hyderabad commissionerates and Telangana districts. How to Check Pending Hyderabad e-Challan Status Online Open the official Telangana State Police e-Challan portal: echallan.tspolice.gov.in/publicview/ . Enter your complete Vehicle Registration Number (supporting TG , TS , and lega...

Numaish (All India Industrial Exhibition) Nampally: Traffic Diversions, Metro & Parking Guide

Last updated: 19 November 2026 Best Way to Reach Numaish: Skip evening gridlock on Mukarram Jahi (MJ) Road by taking the Hyderabad Metro Rail Red Line directly to Gandhi Bhavan Metro Station (right beside Exhibition Grounds) or Nampally Metro Station. Check live evening traffic advisories on @HYDTP or WhatsApp 9010203626 . Every winter from January 1 to February 15 , the All India Industrial Exhibition—popularly known as Numaish —draws lakhs of shoppers and families to the Exhibition Grounds at Nampally. Peak pedestrian and vehicular pressure builds daily between 4:00 PM and midnight , especially on weekends and holidays. To keep Nampally, Abids, and Moazzam Jahi Market moving, Hyderabad Traffic Police enforce recurring evening heavy-vehicle restrictions under Section 21(1)(b) of the Hyderabad City Police Act. Recurring Evening Diversions During Numaish (4:00 PM – Midnight) Vehicle Category & Origin Restricted Direction Evening Diversion Corridor (16:00 – 00:00) TGSRTC Distric...

Hyderabad, Cyberabad & Rachakonda Traffic Police Limits: Complete Jurisdiction Guide

Last updated: 19 November 2026 Important Update: Greater Hyderabad is no longer split only between Hyderabad and Cyberabad. Since the 2016 trifurcation , the metropolitan region is managed by three independent Police Commissionerates : Hyderabad , Cyberabad , and Rachakonda —all unified under one statewide e-Challan portal at echallan.tspolice.gov.in . As Hyderabad expanded rapidly from its historic twin-city core into IT hubs, industrial belts, and outer suburbs, policing boundaries were reorganized twice to keep response times fast. First, Cyberabad Commissionerate was created in 2003–2004 to manage the fast-growing perimeter surrounding core Hyderabad. Later, in October 2016, Telangana carved out the Rachakonda Police Commissionerate from Cyberabad's eastern and southeastern limits. 1. Area-Wise Breakdown of the Three Greater Hyderabad Commissionerates Commissionerate Key Areas & Corridors Covered Primary Official Channels Hyderabad City Traffic Police Core twin c...